Bleeding Gabriel (Middletown) and Multiple Reviews

I found a bunch of reviews of Middletown scanned into a pdf file from an official source. Since it's a pdf file I'll upload it to the gallery for viewing.

Among the reviews was this upsetting image of Matthew as Gabriel.

Edit: 6point7 has been amazingly kind to fiddle with the quality of the scan. Thank you so much!

Bleeding Gabriel (Middletown) and Multiple Reviews